10 Best Mark McGwire Rookie Cards to Collect - Sports Card Sharks (2023)

10 Best Mark McGwire Rookie Cards to Collect - Sports Card Sharks (1)

We use affiliate links and may receive a small commission on purchases from eBay or other partners. Please help support a small business. Read moreabout us.

Jump to the Cards

Hello! If you’re looking for a list of the best Mark McGwire rookie baseball cards, then you’ve come to the right place.

Mark McGwire was one of the most prolific home run hitters in MLB history, and his rookie cards are highly sought-after by collectors.

While investing in Mark McGwire rookie cards can be a sound financial decision, it's important to remember that he also has a number of other accomplishments that make him collectible.

Mark had an incredible rookie season in the MLB for which he was named Rookie of the Year in 1987.

In 1998, McGwire set the single-season home run record with 70 dingers.

Mark was also a five-time All-Star and won three Silver Slugger Awards.

Finally, in 2010, he was inducted into the Baseball Hall of Fame.

We highly recommend adding a Mark McGwire rookie card to your collection as they are a tribute to one of baseball's greatest power hitters.

The experts here atSports Card Sharks have spent countless hours sifting through each and every Mark McGwire rookie card on the market and have compiled a list of the ones we feel are the best of the best.

We hope you find a ton value in our list!

FAQs

How Do We Pick The Best Cards?

The rookie cards we select for our lists are judged based on 3 criteria:

  • Design / Aesthetics
  • Price
  • Rarity

What Makes Us Different?

At Sports Card Sharks, we tend to go against the grain. We typically aren’t buying what everyone else is buying when everyone else is buying it, so if you’re moving with the masses this may not be the right list for you. Adios!

(Video) 25 Valuable Mark McGwire Baseball Cards including his rookie cards

Why Should You Trust Us?

Our Founder is an 80's baby that grew up in the 90's collecting sports cards during the junk wax era.

While card collecting when on hiatus for a couple of decades, that passion was re-sparked in 2020 and we haven't looked back since.

We spend countless hours researching each player and constructing these posts to help you save time and energy so that you can focus on the fun part which is collecting!

Mark McGwire Player Profile

MLB Draft: 1981 (8th round by the Montreal Expos) & 1984 (1st round and 10th overall by the Oakland Athletics)

College: USC

Team(s):Oakland Athletics and St. Louis Cardinals

Position:1B

Height:6' 5"

Weight:215 lbs

Date of Birth: October 1, 1963

All-Star Appearances:12x

World Series Championships:1x (1989)

Career Statistics:View Here

Why We Love Mark McGwire

  • Great nicknames - Big Mac, Big Red, Colossus
  • 1987 Rookie of the Year
  • 3x Silver Slugger
  • 583 career home runs

Our List of the Top Mark McGwire Rookie Cards

10 Best Mark McGwire Rookie Cards to Collect - Sports Card Sharks (2)

(Video) The 15 Most Valuable Topps Baseball Rookie Cards from 2000-2009

1. 1987 Mark McGwire Action Superstars Series IV Rookie Card #76

We kick things off with a bit of an oddball rookie card. You won't find many of these floating around on marketplaces and they're definitely the bottom of the barrel in terms of collecting.

Also Check Out:Ozzie Smith

10 Best Mark McGwire Rookie Cards to Collect - Sports Card Sharks (3)

2. 1987 Mark McGwire Mother's Cookies Swinging Rookie Card #3

This Mark McGwire rookie card is a fun one that you probably won't find on many lists out there. It was produced by the Mother's Cookies brand and features a fantastic image of Mark in his batting motion.

Additional Option:

  • 1987 Mark McGwire Mother's Cookies Portrait Rookie Card #1 [View Here]

Also Check Out:Doc Gooden

10 Best Mark McGwire Rookie Cards to Collect - Sports Card Sharks (4)

3. 1987 Mark McGwire Donruss Rated Rookie Card #46

That "Rated Rookie" badge has to be one of the coolest designed features in the history of sports cards.

The black border definitely makes it difficult to maintain but we think this card design is awesome.

Also Check Out:Shohei Ohtani

10 Best Mark McGwire Rookie Cards to Collect - Sports Card Sharks (5)

4. 1987 Mark McGwire Donruss "The Rookies" Rookie Card #1

In 1987, Donruss also had a secondary set called "The Rookies" and McGwire was feature #1.

You'll notice that the design is very similar to the previous rookie card but features a green border which color matches Mark's uniform.

(Video) Mark McGwire Rookie Cards #shorts #baseball

Also Check Out:Derek Jeter

10 Best Mark McGwire Rookie Cards to Collect - Sports Card Sharks (6)

5. 1987 Mark McGwire Donruss "Diamond Kings" Rookie Card #1

Most trading card purists hate when "inserts" are featured on lists like this because they're not "true" rookie cards, but we prefer to give our readers ALL of the options.

We remember being big fans of these designs while growing up and the Diamond Kings inserts were a big part of what drew us to this set.

Additional Insert Options:

  • 1987 Mark McGwire Donruss "Highlights" Rookie Card #27 [View Here]
  • 1987 Mark McGwire Donruss "Highlights" Rookie Card #46 [View Here]
  • 1987 Mark McGwire Donruss "Highlights" Rookie Card #54 [View Here]
  • 1987 Donruss "Highlights" Mark McGwire & Jose Canseco Rookie Card #40 [View Here]

Also Check Out:Vladimir Guerrero Jr

10 Best Mark McGwire Rookie Cards to Collect - Sports Card Sharks (7)

6. 1987 Mark McGwire Fleer Update Rookie Card #U-76

The blue border really pops on this rookie card and. you get the rare feature of a player actually smiling on a card.

Mark was probably loving all those home runs he was hitting in his rookie season.

Also Check Out: Top Ken Griffey Jr Rookie Cards

10 Best Mark McGwire Rookie Cards to Collect - Sports Card Sharks (8)

7. 1987 Mark McGwire Fleer Baseball's Best Rookie Card #26

Do you think Mark worked out his arms? My goodness. McGwire truly was the best slugger at this time and one of the greatest of all time (we don't care about the steroids stuff in case you were wondering).

Also Check Out:Mike Trout

(Video) Top 25 Most Valuable Baseball Cards from the 1990's - Rookie Cards Only

10 Best Mark McGwire Rookie Cards to Collect - Sports Card Sharks (9)

8. 1987 Mark McGwire Leaf Rated Rookie Card #46

Leaf was Donruss' counterpart to the great north aka Canada.

The designs are identical outside of the logo, however, the Leaf version is much more highly sought-after given the much shorter print run which makes it more rare.

Also Check Out:Luis Robert

10 Best Mark McGwire Rookie Cards to Collect - Sports Card Sharks (10)

9. 1987 Mark McGwire Topps Rookie Card #366

This rookie card is the first time that Mark McGwire was featured in an Oakland Athletics uniform in the Topps set.

It is arguably his 2nd most popular rookie card to the one featured below...

Also Check Out:Juan Gonzalez

10 Best Mark McGwire Rookie Cards to Collect - Sports Card Sharks (11)

10. 1985 Mark McGwire Topps USA Baseball Team Rookie Card

While 1987 is technically considered his rookie season, this 1985 Topps card is considered his first ever mainstream release and therefore is looked at as his flagship rookie card by most collectors.

There is both a regular version and a Tiffany version, with the Tiffany version being the more rare and expensive card.

Also Check Out:Frank Thomas

Mark McGwire Rookie Card Checklist

  • 1987 Mark McGwire Action Superstars Series IV Rookie Card #76
  • 1987 Mark McGwire Mother's Cookies Portrait Rookie Card #1
  • 1987 Mark McGwire Mother's Cookies Swinging Rookie Card #3
  • 1987 Mark McGwire Donruss Rated Rookie Card #46
  • 1987 Mark McGwire Donruss "The Rookies" Rookie Card #1
  • 1987 Mark McGwire Donruss "Highlights" Rookie Card #27
  • 1987 Mark McGwire Donruss "Highlights" Rookie Card #46
  • 1987 Mark McGwire Donruss "Highlights" Rookie Card #54
  • 1987 Donruss "Highlights" Mark McGwire & Jose Canseco Rookie Card #40
  • 1987 Mark McGwire Donruss "Diamond Kings" Rookie Card #1
  • 1987 Mark McGwire Fleer Update Rookie Card #U-76
  • 1987 Mark McGwire Fleer Baseball's Best Rookie Card #26
  • 1987 Mark McGwire Leaf Rated Rookie Card #46
  • 1987 Mark McGwire Topps Rookie Card #366
  • 1985 Mark McGwire Topps USA Baseball Team Rookie Card

Affiliate Disclaimer:The links in the article contain affiliate links and we receive a small commission for any purchase made on eBay. We appreciate your support!

Financial Disclaimer:If you investing in sports cards as an alternative investment, please do your own research and do so at your own risk. We are not financial advisors and this is not financial advice.

(Video) TOP 25 Derek Jeter Rookie Card List - Investing in Jeter RC'S

About the Author:

FAQs

What is the most valuable Mark McGwire rookie card? ›

1. Mark McGwire 1985 Topps Tiffany Rookie #401 PSA 10 - $30,000. To start the list off, we have the quintessential Mark McGwire grail. This 1985 Topps Tiffany rookie takes up seven of the eight highest Big Mac sales ever, and it's one of the most coveted cards from the junk wax era.

What is the error on the 1988 Topps Mark McGwire card? ›

All 1988 Topps error cards
1988 Topps #3 Mark McGwireWhite area behind left foot
1988 Topps #492 Doyle AlexanderWrong date of birth. September 4, not September 5
1988 Topps #493 Mike GreenwellRookie trophy printed over the lettering in his name or touching his name
48 more rows
Apr 22, 2023

What is considered Mark McGwire rookie card? ›

1985 Topps Tiffany Mark McGwire RC #401

His rookie, which is part of a subset featuring members of the 1984 U.S. Olympic team, commanded some of the highest prices ever paid for baseball cards during the first few years of the 21st century. The high gloss Tiffany version of the card yielded the tip-top prices.

Are Darryl Strawberry cards worth anything? ›

The most valuable Card of Darryl Strawberry is currently 1984 Topps Tiffany #182 Darryl Strawberry PSA 10 by Topps from 1984 with a worth of approx. $944.0.

Which brand of rookie cards are most valuable? ›

The most valuable brand of baseball card can vary depending on the specific card, however, Topps is generally the most constantly valuable baseball card brand. Topps is considered the leader of the industry, and rookie cards produced by Topps are often very highly sought after.

Which Ken Griffey Jr rookie card is worth the most? ›

The most valuable Ken Griffey Jr. cards include his 1989 Bowman Tiffany, 1989 Topps Heads Up, and 1989 Upper Deck #1 Star Rookie card. Massive print runs limit the investment value of Griffey's cards. Rally app offers fractionalized shares for valuable cards like 1989 Bowman Tiffany.

Videos

1. Top 50 Most Valuable Cards in My Collection - 2022 Edition
(Baseball Collector)
2. I BOUGHT A HISTORIC 1 MILLION SPORTS CARD COLLECTION! 17 KOBE ROOKIES! JORDANS! HANK AARON! MANTLE!
(For The Love Of It)
3. Baseball Trading Card Pack Opening - Hank Aaron Pull
(MLozada)
4. Why Topps Threw Away The World's Most Valuable Baseball Cards
(The Diamond)
5. The 25 Most Valuable Baseball Cards from the 1980s
(Baseball Card Collector Investor Dealer)
6. PSA Bulk Submission Return!! 27 Cards - Bryce Harper, Mark McGwire, and 2 random Pokémon cards!
(House of Baseball Cards)

References

Top Articles
Latest Posts
Article information

Author: Ms. Lucile Johns

Last Updated: 20/10/2023

Views: 6473

Rating: 4 / 5 (61 voted)

Reviews: 92% of readers found this page helpful

Author information

Name: Ms. Lucile Johns

Birthday: 1999-11-16

Address: Suite 237 56046 Walsh Coves, West Enid, VT 46557

Phone: +59115435987187

Job: Education Supervisor

Hobby: Genealogy, Stone skipping, Skydiving, Nordic skating, Couponing, Coloring, Gardening

Introduction: My name is Ms. Lucile Johns, I am a successful, friendly, friendly, homely, adventurous, handsome, delightful person who loves writing and wants to share my knowledge and understanding with you.